Heisman Trophy Race 2026: Fan Guide to the Contenders
The Heisman Trophy race just changed overnight. After Week 9, three players were bunched at the top of the oddsboard: Ohio State receiver Jeremiah Smith, Miami quarterback Darian Mensah and Miami receiver Malachi Toney. Then, on Wednesday, Nov. 4, news broke that Toney has a high ankle sprain and will undergo surgery, knocking him out of the regular season and off the betting board. That turns a three-man sprint into a two-man race with a pack of quarterbacks chasing. This fan guide walks through where every serious contender stands, the games that could decide it, how the 931 Heisman votes are actually counted, and the dates to circle before the trophy is handed out on Dec. 12.
The Heisman Trophy race at a glance
Here is the short version for fans who just want the headlines. According to FOX Sports, which cited ESPN's Pete Thamel, Toney's injury is a high ankle sprain that requires surgery, with a return expected for the College Football Playoff. The typical recovery timeline is at least four weeks. Before the news, Toney was the second choice at +300. After it, he was no longer listed at FanDuel Sportsbook.
- New favorite: Jeremiah Smith moved back to the top at +160, just ahead of Darian Mensah at +165 (FOX Sports, odds as of Nov. 4).
- Biggest mover: Notre Dame quarterback CJ Carr rose to +550, third on the board.
- SEC hopefuls: Ole Miss quarterback Trinidad Chambliss sits at +950, and LSU's Sam Leavitt is a long shot at +3500 (Sports Illustrated).
- Game of the week: No. 1 Miami visits No. 11 Notre Dame on Saturday night, a direct Mensah vs. Carr showdown (CBS Sports).
Odds are a snapshot of how sportsbooks see the race, not a prediction, and they change every week. We use them here only as a scoreboard for who is in the conversation.
Why last year's winner leaves the door wide open
To understand why this race feels so unsettled, start with the man who won it last time. FOX Sports recaps Fernando Mendoza's 2025 season at Indiana as close to perfect: a 16-0 record, a national championship, the 2025 Heisman Trophy and then the No. 1 overall pick in the 2026 NFL Draft by the Raiders. With Mendoza gone to the pros, there is no returning winner, and no single quarterback has run away with the 2026 race the way he did.
That is part of why a wide receiver is a real threat this year. Smith and Toney spent October trading big games, and the market treated them as co-headliners alongside Mensah. A receiver winning would not be unheard of. Desmond Howard, pictured below with the trophy statuette in 1991, is one of the best-known examples. But voters usually lean toward quarterbacks, and that tension is what makes this November so interesting.
The contenders: 2026 Heisman Trophy odds
Sports Illustrated published the fullest version of the updated FanDuel board after the Toney news. No other player was shorter than +10000. Here is that list, with positions and schools where the sources name them.
| # | Player | Pos. | School | Odds (FanDuel) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Jeremiah Smith | WR | Ohio State | +160 |
| 2 | Darian Mensah | QB | Miami | +165 |
| 3 | CJ Carr | QB | Notre Dame | +550 |
| 4 | Trinidad Chambliss | QB | Ole Miss | +950 |
| 5 | Sam Leavitt | QB | LSU | +3500 |
| 6 | Gunner Stockton | — | — | +4000 |
| 7 | Drew Mestemaker | QB | — | +6000 |
| 8 | Gio Lopez | QB | — | +8000 |
| 9 | Jesse Legree | — | — | +8000 |
Source: Sports Illustrated; top four also confirmed by FOX Sports as of Nov. 4. A dash means the source did not list that detail.
![]() Logo © The Ohio State University, used for identification Ohio State Buckeyes |
![]() Logo © University of Miami, used for identification Miami Hurricanes |
![]() Logo © University of Notre Dame, used for identification Notre Dame Fighting Irish |
Jeremiah Smith, Ohio State: the record-breaker back on top
Jeremiah Smith has the best résumé of any receiver in the country by one key measure: history. FOX Sports reports his 40 career receiving touchdowns passed Braylon Edwards for the most in Big Ten history, adding to his Ohio State career records for receptions and receiving yards.
The problem has been the quarterback situation. Starter Julian Sayin is out indefinitely with an injury to his throwing arm, according to CBS Sports, and freshman Luke Fahey's limitations showed against USC. CBS adds that Smith was held in check in that game until USC softened up with a two-score lead. SI notes Smith has failed to reach 100 yards in three straight weeks, and that Toney actually had more catches (73) while matching Smith's 13 receiving touchdowns.
So why is he the favorite again? Because the player chasing his receiving numbers just went down. CBS argues that if Ohio State keeps peppering Smith with targets, he should put up numbers, even if they are not always efficient. His next test is a top-25 matchup against Oregon this weekend. The bigger question, CBS says, is whether the Buckeyes can avoid one or two more losses, which could dent his chances.
What Smith needs in November
- A breakout game against Oregon to end the run of sub-100-yard weeks.
- Steady production with a freshman quarterback throwing to him.
- Ohio State wins, since team success keeps a receiver on voters' minds.
Darian Mensah, Miami: the quarterback of the No. 1 team
Darian Mensah has the classic Heisman profile: a quarterback on an unbeaten, top-ranked team. FOX Sports says Miami is 8-0 and No. 1 in the country. Mensah completed 22 of 29 passes for 274 yards, three touchdowns and no interceptions in the win over North Carolina, and he has 25 touchdown passes against just one interception on the season.
His most eye-popping number is against pressure. Against the blitz, Mensah has completed 58 of 66 passes (87.9%) for an FBS-high 15 touchdowns and no interceptions, according to FOX Sports. He has more touchdown passes against the blitz than incompletions.
Toney's injury cuts both ways for him. CBS Sports calls it "a sick twist of fate" that the candidate who may benefit most is Toney's own teammate: the two were splitting votes, and now Mensah can make his push alone. On the other hand, SI points out that Mensah's odds also moved after the injury, a sign that oddsmakers expect the Miami offense as a whole to take a hit without its top target.
What Mensah needs in November
- A road win at Notre Dame without his best receiver.
- Keeping that 25-to-1 touchdown-to-interception ratio intact.
- Miami staying unbeaten heading into the playoff picture.
CJ Carr, Notre Dame: the quarterback with the biggest opportunity
CJ Carr has been sitting just behind the top tier for weeks. Now he gets the one game that can change everything. FOX Sports reports Carr completed 19 of 29 passes for 210 yards and two touchdowns in a bounce-back win over Navy. On the season he has 18 touchdowns and one interception on 222 attempts.
His calling card is ball security. Among FBS quarterbacks with at least 150 attempts, Carr ranks second in lowest interception percentage (0.45%) and third in touchdown-to-interception ratio, and he has gone 145 consecutive pass attempts without an interception (FOX Sports). CBS adds that he averages 8.3 yards per attempt.
What has held him back? CBS says Notre Dame's schedule has not done him favors, he has not needed huge numbers to win, and the loss to BYU hurt his stock. There may be openings on Saturday: North Carolina's Billy Edwards Jr. threw for 341 yards against the Miami secondary last week. SI goes further, writing that there is a real case for Carr to take the top spot if Notre Dame beats Miami, and that whichever team wins that game will likely have the Heisman favorite unless Smith has a big day.
The SEC quarterbacks lurking
Before Toney got hurt, CBS Sports writes, the SEC did not really have an obvious Heisman candidate. Two quarterbacks now have a cracked door to walk through.
Trinidad Chambliss, Ole Miss (+950)
FOX Sports says Chambliss bounced back against Auburn, completing 22 of 34 passes for 263 yards with two touchdowns and an interception, plus 65 rushing yards and another score. He is one of just three FBS players this season with multiple games of at least 250 passing yards, 50 rushing yards and both a passing and rushing touchdown. CBS notes he missed his chance to impress voters against Texas, but No. 2 Georgia visits Oxford in primetime this weekend. A win there would put him back in the New York conversation.
Sam Leavitt, LSU (+3500)
Leavitt, a high-profile transfer from Arizona State, is the more interesting SEC name in the CBS writer's opinion. His early-season games were marked by head-scratching turnovers, but over the last few weeks he has raised his level without critical mistakes. With LSU entering the most important stretch of its season, CBS says his stock could look very different by Thanksgiving.
Malachi Toney: out of the race, not out of the season
It is worth pausing on what Toney had built before the injury. SI lists 73 catches for 1,027 yards and 13 touchdowns, including two scores in the Week 9 win over North Carolina, and calls him a real case for the top receiver in college football. According to the Thamel report cited by FOX Sports and SI, surgery should allow him to return for the College Football Playoff.
For Miami fans, that is the silver lining. The Heisman is a regular-season award in practice, because ballots are due before the playoff is played. A healthy Toney in December and January may matter far more to the Hurricanes than any trophy.
Week 10 games that could decide the Heisman Trophy race
Every source we read circled the same weekend. Here is the viewing list for fans tracking the race.
| Game | Heisman angle | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Miami at No. 11 Notre Dame (Saturday night, South Bend) | Mensah vs. Carr head-to-head; Miami without Toney | CBS Sports, SI |
| Ohio State vs. Oregon (top-25 matchup) | Can Smith break out with a freshman QB? | CBS Sports |
| No. 2 Georgia at Ole Miss (primetime, Oxford) | Chambliss's redemption shot | CBS Sports |
| LSU's November stretch | Leavitt's late climb | CBS Sports |
Want the full preview of the biggest one? Our Miami vs Notre Dame fan guide covers the matchup itself, and the Ohio State vs Oregon guide breaks down the Buckeyes' test.
How Heisman voting works
Fans argue about the Heisman all season, but only a few hundred people actually decide it. According to Heisman.com, the electorate is built in three parts:
- 870 media voters. The country is split into six sections (Far West, Mid Atlantic, Mid West, North East, South and Southwest), each with 145 media votes.
- 60 former winners. Every living Heisman winner gets a vote.
- 1 fan vote. Since 1999, the public's choice counts as one ballot.
That adds up to 931 voters for the 2026 race. Each ballot must list a first, second and third choice. A first-place vote is worth three points, second place two points and third place one point. Heisman.com says the point system was created to reduce sectional favoritism, which is why a player who is popular in only one region rarely wins.
The ballot also spells out eligibility: the winner must be a bona fide student of an accredited college or university, including the U.S. service academies, and must comply with NCAA bylaws for student-athletes.
How fans can vote
The single fan ballot comes from the Heisman Fan Vote. Heisman.com says fans can vote once per day on the Heisman website and once per day on each social media platform by posting "@HeismanTrophy I want to vote for #PlayerName." The fan vote leaderboard updates every Friday at 12 p.m. ET.
2026 Heisman key dates
Put these on the family calendar now. All dates come from Heisman.com.
| Date | What happens |
|---|---|
| Thursday, Dec. 3 | Ballots go out to electors, including online login credentials |
| Saturday, Dec. 5 | Online voting opens at 5 p.m. EST |
| Monday, Dec. 7 | Ballots due at 5 p.m. EST; finalists announced that evening |
| Saturday, Dec. 12 | Winner announced at the televised Heisman Ceremony on ABC |
Notice that the deadline falls before any playoff game. That is why November, plus conference championship weekend, carries so much weight for every contender on this list.
How to follow the race as a fan
Build a Saturday-night watch plan
This weekend stacks the key games into one evening slate. Set up the main screen for Miami at Notre Dame and keep a second device on Ohio State and Ole Miss updates. A simple shared scorecard (passing yards, touchdowns, turnovers) for each contender makes the night more fun for the whole room.
Track a few honest stats, not just highlights
The numbers in this guide are a good starting kit: Mensah's touchdown-to-interception ratio, Carr's interception-free streak, Smith's weekly yardage and whether each team wins. Voters see the highlights too, but those stats tell you who is really separating.
Plan the Dec. 12 ceremony night
The ceremony lands right in holiday season, so many families fold it into a December get-together. Keep it simple: snacks, a warm blanket on the couch, and everyone's pick written down before the envelope opens.
Mind the odds talk
Odds can be a fun way to see who is trending, but they are not a reason to bet. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, SI lists the 1-800-GAMBLER helpline.
Bottom line
The 2026 Heisman Trophy race is now a toss-up between a record-setting receiver and the quarterback of the No. 1 team, with CJ Carr one big Saturday away from joining them. Jeremiah Smith (+160) and Darian Mensah (+165) are separated by a hair, Malachi Toney is out until the playoff, and the SEC quarterbacks still have time. By the time ballots are due on Dec. 7, this weekend in South Bend may look like the night the race was decided.
Related fan guides
- Miami vs Notre Dame 2026: Top-5 Showdown Fan Guide
- Ohio State vs Oregon 2026: Week 10 Fan Guide
- College Football Playoff Rankings 2026: First Top 25 Guide
- Alabama vs LSU 2026: Fan Guide to the Last Annual Clash
- BYU vs Utah 2026: First Top-10 Holy War Fan Guide
FAQ
Who is the favorite to win the 2026 Heisman Trophy?
As of Nov. 4, Ohio State wide receiver Jeremiah Smith was the favorite at +160 at FanDuel Sportsbook, just ahead of Miami quarterback Darian Mensah at +165, according to FOX Sports and Sports Illustrated.
What happened to Malachi Toney?
Miami's star receiver has a high ankle sprain and will undergo surgery, according to ESPN's Pete Thamel as cited by FOX Sports. The typical recovery is at least four weeks, with a return expected for the College Football Playoff.
When is the 2026 Heisman Trophy ceremony?
Heisman.com lists Saturday, Dec. 12, 2026, with the winner announced on the televised ceremony on ABC. Finalists are announced on the evening of Monday, Dec. 7.
How many people vote for the Heisman Trophy?
There are 931 voters for 2026: 870 media members across six regions, 60 living former winners and one combined fan vote, according to Heisman.com.
How does Heisman voting work?
Each voter ranks three players. A first-place vote earns three points, second place two points and third place one point. The player with the most total points wins.
Can fans vote for the Heisman?
Yes. Fans can vote once per day on the Heisman website and once per day per social platform by posting @HeismanTrophy with their pick. Together, the fan vote counts as one ballot.
Sources
- FOX Sports: 2026 Heisman Trophy odds, Malachi Toney falls off board amid injury
- CBS Sports (Austin Nivison): Malachi Toney injury reshapes Heisman race
- Sports Illustrated: 2026 Heisman Trophy odds after the Malachi Toney injury
- Heisman.com: Heisman balloting history and 2026 key dates
This is an independent fan article. Design Trend is not affiliated with or endorsed by the NFL, NBA, NCAA, NHL or any team mentioned.
SHARE







0 comment
Be the first to comment